ANSWER

Certainly, qualitative risk assessment can be a valuable tool for evaluating potential hazards and risks in various situations. However, as you rightly pointed out, one of its drawbacks is the subjectivity that comes with individual perceptions of risk. I can certainly share an experience from my previous job where such differences in risk evaluation criteria became evident.

In my previous role as a project manager in a construction company, we were tasked with building a large commercial complex. During the planning phase, we encountered a situation where we had to evaluate the risks associated with a particular construction method. The method involved using a new type of scaffolding system that promised to be more efficient but had limited track record in our region.

I had a coworker, let’s call him John, who had been with the company for over a decade and had worked on numerous projects. He had a wealth of experience and was quite conservative when it came to adopting new construction methods. John was of the opinion that we should stick with the traditional scaffolding system that we had used successfully in the past. He believed that the new system posed too many unknowns and potential risks.

On the other hand, I was more open to considering the new system. I had researched it thoroughly and believed that it could significantly reduce construction time and costs. I felt that with proper training and precautions, we could manage the associated risks effectively. My perception of risk was influenced by my belief in the benefits of the new system and my confidence in our ability to mitigate any potential issues.

Our differing perceptions of risk created tension within the project team. John’s conservative stance was driven by his years of experience and the desire to avoid any potential setbacks, while my willingness to take the risk was rooted in a desire for innovation and efficiency.

This situation highlights how individual perception of risk can contribute to risk-taking behavior. John’s perception of higher risk led him to advocate for a more cautious approach, while my perception of lower risk led me to support the adoption of the new system. It’s essential to recognize that our personal backgrounds, experiences, and risk tolerances influenced our views.

In the end, we conducted a thorough risk assessment, involving input from various team members and experts. We implemented additional safety measures and provided extensive training to our workers. While there were some challenges along the way, the project was ultimately successful, and the new scaffolding system proved to be more efficient as we had hoped.

This experience taught me the importance of balancing different perspectives in risk assessment. It’s crucial to consider not only the technical aspects of risk but also the human factor, including individual perceptions and attitudes. In hazardous situations, a diverse team with varying risk perceptions can lead to a more comprehensive and effective risk management strategy.

QUESTION

Description