MILH 422 AMU Contemporary Issues In Peacekeeping with Historical Context Essay
2. Fact-finding missions prior to UN peacekeeping: Fact-finding missions play a crucial role in determining the necessity and feasibility of UN peacekeeping interventions. These missions gather essential information about the conflict’s dynamics, local conditions, potential challenges, and the willingness of parties to cooperate. They help in assessing the risks and potential impact of peacekeeping operations. Fact-finding missions can aid the UN in making informed decisions about whether to intervene, the scope of intervention, and the required resources.
3. “Contracting out” for peacekeeping: Contracting out peacekeeping operations involves hiring private security firms or military contractors to perform certain tasks within a peacekeeping mission. While there might be advantages like rapid deployment and specialized skills, there are also significant concerns. These include issues of accountability, transparency, and potential conflicts of interest. Contracting out can compromise the UN’s credibility and undermine its principles. It’s important to carefully weigh the positives against the negatives and establish clear guidelines for contracting out to ensure ethical and effective peacekeeping.
7. Negative views of women in peacekeeping: While there’s growing recognition of the positive role women play in peacekeeping, some negative views persist. Critics argue that women might be physically less suited for combat roles, potentially jeopardizing the safety of peacekeeping units. Concerns about cultural insensitivity might arise in conservative societies, where the presence of women in security roles could be seen as a challenge to traditional norms. Additionally, the integration of women could require additional resources for facilities and support, which might divert resources from other crucial areas.
8. Most important aspect of the Brahimi Report: The Brahimi Report, a landmark document in UN peacekeeping reform, identified the need for a shift from traditional peacekeeping to multidimensional operations. Its most important aspect is the emphasis on comprehensive approaches that combine military, political, humanitarian, and development efforts. This recognition of the complex nature of conflicts and the need for holistic responses has influenced contemporary peacekeeping strategies and interventions, aiming for more effective and sustainable outcomes.
9. Improvements in an ongoing PKO: In an ongoing peacekeeping operation, fostering stronger ties with local communities and engaging in community-based conflict resolution initiatives could enhance the mission’s effectiveness. Establishing collaborative relationships with local leaders, NGOs, and grassroots organizations can provide a deeper understanding of the conflict’s root causes and help tailor interventions accordingly. Moreover, a focus on capacity building within the host country’s security forces can contribute to the gradual transition of security responsibilities, promoting long-term stability.
Remember to integrate relevant course readings and primary sources to support your arguments, adhering to proper citation guidelines.
QUESTION
Description
2. Justify whether or not fact-finding missions should be used prior to the UN going into an area for peacekeeping?
3. Discuss whether “contracting out” for peacekeeping is an effective move for the UN? Do the positives outweigh the negatives?
7. We have spoken in great length about women in peacekeeping and many have been positive role models. Play devil’s advocate and discuss the negative view of women in peacekeeping roles.
8. Chapter 5 briefly discusses the Brahimi Report. What is the most important aspect of this report and why?
9. Discuss what can be done differently in an ongoing PKO in which you have some experience in the state or region.
Hint: Keep your eye on important historical factors in each of these questions and cite relevant journal articles and/or primary sources that support your arguments. Also, cite your required readings from this week as the conceptual basis of your answer.
Your initial post should be at least 350 words. Please respond with three follow-ups to other students. Responses should be a minimum of 150 words. The initial required post should be supported by course readings using parenthetical references. Click here for a copy of the discussion rubric.
Follow the Turabian Quick Guide style for author/date. Click on the tab in the middle of the page.
Initial Post Due: Thursday, by 11:55pm ET
Responses Due: Sunday, by 11:55pm ET