SDSU Political Science the England Civil War Question
ANSWER
1) How would you describe the atmosphere at the Putney Debates?
It would help if you thought about the setting, the participants, and the overall dynamics of the Putney Debates while analyzing the mood that pervaded these conversations. Here is a method you can use, step by step:
Set the Scene in the Introduction
Explain briefly the Putney Debates and why they were important to start your contemplation. Mention how these discussions occurred when political and social tensions were particularly high in England.
Players and Background:
Identify who the primary Putney Debates participants were. Important individuals like Oliver Cromwell, the Levellers, and others present would fall under this category.
Please give a brief history of the Levellers and their philosophy. Describe their political philosophy and the setting where they presented their arguments during the discussions.
Climate and Dynamics:
Discuss the debates’ overall mood. Were they tense, direct, argumentative, or cooperative? Use passages from the book or other references to support your description of the atmosphere.
Examine the interactions between the various participants. There may have been coalitions, changes in beliefs, or conflicts. Were there any standout discussion moments or turning points?
Ideological Conflicts
Describe some of the most significant ideological conflicts that occurred during the discussions. Disagreements on topics like universal suffrage, the function of the military, and governmental structure may fall under this category.
Give instances of particular arguments or assertions that demonstrate these ideological conflicts.
Historical Importance and Impact:
Talk about the Putney Debates’ effects and historical relevance as you wrap up your contemplation. What impact did the discussions have on the greater political conversation then? Did they change history or bring forth any noticeable changes?
Remember to cite passages from the book to back up your arguments, especially those from pages 61 to 118. You can use quotes, paraphrases, and summaries to support your analysis.
Remember that your reflection should have a clear and ordered format with an introduction, many body paragraphs, and a conclusion. Your writing will flow more easily, and your analysis will be simpler to understand.
The strategy will change depending on the issue you select. However, the most important thing is to examine the pertinent passages from the book carefully and offer well-reasoned conclusions in your reflection.
Question Description
I’m working on a political science writing question and need the explanation and answer to help me learn.
Select ONE of the following questions. Write a reflection. Pages 61-118.
Book: The Levellers, The Putney Debates (Verso; introduction by Geoffrey Robertson)
ISBN: 9781788731416
select one question from below.
1) How would you characterize the general atmosphere at the Putney Debates?
2) Why did the Levellers bring up for discussion and vote the “Agreement of the People” instead of “The Case of the Army Truly Stated”? What seems to be Cromwell’s attitude toward this proposal, and are there reasons to believe his real attitude might have been different than what transpired at the Putney Debates?
3) What is Ireton’s most fundamental objection to the Levellers’ proposal for universal suffrage? In addition, why does he repeatedly conjure up the image of foreigners on English soil?